Enforcement in Indonesia
Sanctions
In Indonesia, the sanctions for breaches of data privacy are found under the relevant legislation and are essentially fines. Imprisonment may be imposed in severe instances, such as in the event of intentional infringement.
Enforcement by the PDP Agency (administrative sanctions)
Violations of certain articles in the PDP Law are subject to administrative sanctions. These administrative sanctions, which shall be imposed by the PDP Agency, are as follows:
- written warning;
- temporary suspension of personal data processing activities;
- deletion or destruction of personal data; and / or
- administrative fines.
With regard to administrative fines, the PDP Law stipulates that the maximum fine is 2% of the concerned party's annual income or revenue. Further provisions on administrative sanctions and the procedures for the imposition of administrative fines will be provided in Government Regulations.
Enforcement by the public prosecutor (criminal sanctions)
- Every person is prohibited from unlawfully obtaining or collecting personal data not belonging to themselves, and with the intention of benefiting themselves or another person which may result in the loss for the data subject. Violation of this is subject to maximum imprisonment of five (5) years and / or a maximum fine of IDR 5 billion (±USD 334,000);
- Every person is prohibited from unlawfully disclosing personal data that does not belong to themselves. Violation of this is subject to maximum imprisonment of four (4) years and / or a maximum fine of IDR 4 billion (±USD 267,000);
- Every person is prohibited from using personal data that does not belong to such person in a manner that contravenes the law. Violation of this is subject to maximum imprisonment of five (5) years and / or a maximum fine of IDR 5 billion (±USD 334,000);
- Every person is prohibited from creating false personal data or fake personal data with the intention of benefiting themselves or other persons that may cause harm to other persons. Violation of this is subject to maximum imprisonment of six (6) years and / or a maximum fine of IDR 6 billion (±USD 400,000).
Additional penalties may also be imposed in the form of confiscation of profits and / or assets obtained or proceeds from criminal acts and indemnity payment.
If the criminal act is committed by a corporate entity, the PDP Law stipulates that criminal sanctions will be imposed only in the form of criminal fines. These fines will be imposed on the management, controller, instructor, beneficial owner, and / or the corporation itself. The administrative fines for corporate entities can be up to 10 times the maximum fines for individuals.
Additional criminal sanctions that may be imposed on corporate entities, include:
- confiscation of profits and / or assets obtained or proceeds from criminal acts;
- suspension of all or part of the business of the corporation;
- permanent prohibition on certain activities;
- closure of all or part of the business premises and / or activities of the corporation;
- fulfilment of the neglected obligation;
- payment of compensation;
- revocation of licenses; and / or
- dissolution of the corporation.
Since the above provisions relate to prohibited conducts related to personal data that shall be enforced by the public prosecutor, these would already have effect since the enactment of the PDP Law.
Enforcement by the KOMDIGI (administrative sanctions)
Considering that there is no specific data protection authority yet formed and operating (which with the recent enactment of the PDP Law is intended to be assumed by the PDP Agency), therefore, reference hereinbelow would still apply, and it is currently still the KOMDIGI that is responsible for monitoring and regulating data protection (in the context of personal data in electronic systems).
The KOMDIGI has the right to request data and information from the electronic system operator (data controller / processor) for the purpose of protecting personal data.
It may also enforce non-complying parties by imposing administrative sanctions in the form of:
- written warnings;
- temporary restriction / suspension of its business activities;
- administrative fines (in coordination with the relevant sector’s regulatory authority). The regulation does not specify the amount of administrative fines or the procedure to impose such fines;
- restriction to the access of the electronic system and / or information / data; and / or
- the business actor being excluded from certain registration list, and / or
- online publication on the website.
The ultimate sanction in MOCI Reg. 5/2020 is the blocking of access to the private electronic system operator’s (PSE’s) electronic systems in Indonesia. Access can be granted again once the private PSE has fulfilled its obligations.
However, as mentioned earlier, it does not rule out the possible enforcement by:
- other relevant sector’s regulatory authority (in the event the data controller / processor is subject to a regulated sector) which may also impose certain other administrative sanctions; and / or
- the law enforcement agency (prosecutor) if the non-compliance implies a criminal offense, which may subject the accused with imprisonment and / or fines.
Banking Law
Under Article 47 paragraph (2) of the Banking Law, any commissioner, director or employee of a bank or its affiliates who intentionally provides information which has to be kept confidential may be sentenced to imprisonment for not less than two (2) years but not more than four (4) years, and fined at least IDR 4 billion (±USD 267,000) but not more than IDR 8 billion (±USD 534,000).
Capital Market Law
Under the Capital Market Law, the FSA is empowered to impose the following administrative sanctions for breaches of the provisions dealing with data protection. The sanctions include:
- A written reminder;
- A fine;
- Limitations on business;
- Suspension of business;
- Revocation of business license;
- Cancellation of approval; and / or
- Cancellation of registration.
Right to file a complaint
The PDP Law provides personal data subjects with the right to file a complaint against automated decision making.
Under the General Data Protection Regulations, an affected individual has the right to file a civil claim to the relevant electronic system operator (data controller / data processor) for losses incurred. On the other hand, it is also provided with the right to make complaints related to data protection infringements to the DITJEN APTIKA within the KOMDIGI if there has been:
- no written notification made by the electronic system operator (data controller / processor) to the data subject concerning a data breach; or
- losses have been incurred by the data subject due to a data breach.
In addition, the general right to file a complaint is embedded in the Indonesian Civil Code, which provides that any party may claim for civil liability if any loss suffered may be evidenced to be resulting due to another party’s unlawful act.
